Imagine a world where innovation was blocked by tradition alone. This unfortunate scenario is often a reality in businesses that have long relied on established systems. Design thinking—an approach that emphasizes empathy, collaboration, and iterative problem-solving—has become a powerful catalyst for innovation. But despite its potential, traditional industries frequently encounter resistance to adopting this paradigm. Whether it’s rooted in misunderstanding or a fear of upheaval, this skepticism limits progress. For organizations seeking to remain competitive in the modern landscape, learning to embrace design thinking could mean the difference between adapting and becoming obsolete.
Understanding Design Thinking
Defining Design Thinking
At its core, design thinking is a human-centered approach to innovation that integrates the perspectives of end users into every step of the problem-solving process. The methodology breaks free of traditional linear models, instead emphasizing a non-linear framework that includes five main stages: empathy, problem definition, ideation, prototyping, and testing. Empathy focuses on truly understanding the needs, emotions, and desires of target users, while iteration encourages rapid experimentation and refinement. By not adhering to rigid procedures, design thinking nurtures creativity and practical solutions that address real-world challenges. Unlike traditional processes that focus on efficiency and cost-reduction, design thinking prioritizes user experiences, paving the way for products and services that are not only useful but deeply relevant.
The Relevance of Design Thinking in Traditional Industries
Why is there such urgency for traditional industries—manufacturing, healthcare, or even finance—to consider modern approaches like design thinking? The answer lies in the evolving marketplace and consumer expectations. Users today seek personalized, intuitive solutions to their problems. In manufacturing, for example, a company that implements a more customer-focused design process may discover ways to optimize product usability, safety, and even environmental impact. Similarly, in healthcare, design thinking could help address patient care inefficiencies by embedding empathy and user-centered methodologies within service delivery. Ultimately, as industries encounter fast-paced technological advancements and fluctuating consumer demands, design thinking offers a structured method to foster innovation, improve customer experiences, and secure competitive advantage.
Common Misconceptions and Resistance Factors
Misunderstanding the Process
A significant factor that feeds resistance is misunderstanding. Especially in traditional workplaces where precise, regimented workflows are established, design thinking is often misinterpreted as a highly informal or chaotic process with no structure. Specialists in these industries may mistakenly perceive design thinking’s iterative style as impractical—fearing that the emphasis on trial-and-error experimentation clashes with existing production models built on precision. There’s also trepidation that the “empathy” phase is somehow non-essential or “soft,” leading leadership to dismiss design thinking as unscientific. These misconceptions can often derail an otherwise fruitful initiative before it even begins.
Fear of Change
Resistance to design thinking is frequently rooted in an aversion to change. Human beings naturally lean toward familiarity, and introducing a new workflow—even one as flexible as design thinking—incites a level of discomfort. Employees may fear they’ll lose their jobs if the process suggests inefficiencies in their work. There’s also concern from management that adopting new methods could create an environment of uncertainty, in which results don’t immediately materialize. Change, by its very nature, brings with it anxiety about the “unknown,” and established industries—with rigid structures based on consistency—may find this particularly troubling. This is why cultivating an understanding of design thinking and demonstrating its value early on can be essential for successful implementation.
Strategies to Overcome Resistance
1. Leadership Buy-In
The journey to adopting design thinking must start from the top. Leadership teams act as cultural architects of organizations, meaning they are instrumental in championing and embracing any new methodology. To push through barriers, leaders need to articulate the value of design thinking clearly, linking it to the organization’s objectives— such as improving customer experience, speeding innovation, or outpacing competitors. They should lead by example, exhibiting curiosity and a willingness to experiment. If employees see their top-level executives engaging with design thinking, they are more likely to reconsider their own reservations and jump onboard.
2. Education and Training
Education is a powerful tool for demystifying design thinking. Comprehensive workshops and hands-on training sessions can clarify how the methodology really works, breaking down each of the five stages into tangible actions. Sharing real-world examples of how design thinking has driven success in other industries can provide immediate relatability and alleviate concerns. For example, training programs that present cases from companies outside of traditional boundaries show executives and employees that this approach isn’t solely reserved for startups; it’s adaptable, regardless of the industry. Guided ideation sessions can show teams the benefits of iteration and co-creation, while removing fears of chaos.
3. Pilot Projects
Change is easier to embrace when it’s proven. Rather than weaving design thinking into the fabric of the entire organization at once, start with small, focused pilot projects. These initiatives should target specific challenges where design thinking offers a strong likelihood of delivering quick wins. Once successful, those pilot projects serve as tangible case studies within the organization, demonstrating the approach doesn’t disrupt routines—and instead generates effective solutions.
4. Creating a Collaborative Culture
Design thinking thrives on collaboration—and collaboration thrives within a constructive, open-minded culture. Facilitating communication, ideation, and breaking down silos should become part of the company DNA to encourage smoother implementation. Building cross-functional teams that incorporate individuals from varied departments (engineering, marketing, sales, etc.) mirrors the collaborative ethos of design thinking. The goal is to reframe problems from multiple perspectives, ensuring ideas stem from a diversity of viewpoints. This intersection of skills and knowledge from across the organization opens employees up to seeing design thinking as a natural extension of collaborative innovation.
Supporting Examples and Case Studies
Case Study: GE Healthcare
In 2012, GE Healthcare managed to break through a massive hurdle by utilizing design thinking. The medical imaging division faced an interesting problem: patients—especially children—were intimidated by MRI machines, reducing the number of successful scans. By approaching the problem from the patient’s perspective rather than a technological one, the team used design thinking to create the Adventure Series—a line of MRI machines that transformed the procedure into a story-driven experience, making kids less afraid. The outcome was not only positive for the patients but also boosted scan completions and patient throughput for hospitals.
Statistics and Industry Insights
According to a 2021 IBM study, teams leading with design thinking generated a 300% higher return on investment and slashed project time by as much as 75%. Furthermore, McKinsey’s Design Index found that companies that prioritized design thinking outperformed industry benchmarks, producing 32% more revenue and 56% higher total returns to shareholders when compared to competitors without design-thinking strategies. These findings underscore the transformative financial impacts behind design thinking, especially within traditionally slow-to-change industries.
Challenges and Obstacles
Identifying Potential Pitfalls
Despite having effective strategies, companies may still encounter roadblocks while attempting to integrate design thinking. One prevalent obstacle happens when teams silo design thinking practices within a specific department—such as the design or innovation team—rather than embracing it organization-wide. Another challenge is unrealistic expectations that results will materialize immediately, misunderstanding that design thinking involves an iterative process and that multiple rounds of refinement may be needed to achieve breakthroughs. Additionally, resistance from veteran employees, whose processes haven’t previously included empathy-based methodologies, could degrade the widespread adoption of these practices within teams.
Suggestions for Navigating Obstacles
To mitigate these challenges, it’s crucial to set the right expectations from the beginning. Leadership needs to frame design thinking as a continuous, evolving process, encouraging tolerance for failure and iteration. Clear communication through workshops and training should emphasize that design thinking isn’t just a “designer’s job”—it’s a universal approach that can complement existing task-specific structures. In terms of resistance from skeptical employees, fostering open dialogue through internal focus groups can provide a space to address concerns and feedback, creating a cycle of trust that supports wider adaptation.
Conclusion
Traditional industries can no longer rely on the old ways of doing things and hope to excel in a fast-changing world. Design thinking is the bridge between old paradigms and modern, competitive strategies. The key takeaway is that the adoption of design thinking requires persistence, flexibility, and patience. However, leadership buy-in, targeted education, fostering collaboration, and utilizing pilot projects can accelerate the shift from skepticism to acceptance. The pathway may not be easy, but the results—enhanced innovation, customer satisfaction, and operational agility—are well worth overcoming the initial hesitations.
Call to Action
If your organization is interested in gaining deeper insights into design thinking or attending a workshop to better understand how these practices can be applied, we invite you to subscribe to our newsletter or visit our website for upcoming events and resources!